![]() |
| Cochiti Golf Club |
New Mexico is known for spectacular golf.
From the high desert around Albuquerque and Santa Fe to the mountain scenery surrounding Ruidoso, the Land of Enchantment has plenty of courses that combine dramatic scenery with memorable golf.
But not every course is getting rave reviews.
We looked at golfer ratings and reviews on sites including GolfPass and TripAdvisor to find the New Mexico courses that are generating the most criticism. Rather than simply picking courses with the lowest possible rating, we gave more weight to courses with a meaningful number of reviews.
One important caveat: Golf-course conditions can change dramatically from season to season, and several of these courses have golfers reporting recent improvements. So consider this a snapshot of online golfer sentiment—not a permanent verdict.
Here are three of the lowest-rated New Mexico golf courses we found.
1. Cochiti Golf Club — Cochiti Lake
GolfPass rating: 1.7/5 from 29 reviews
Cochiti Golf Club may be the biggest surprise on this list.
Designed by Robert Trent Jones Jr., the course has the pedigree and scenery to be one of New Mexico's premier golf experiences. But its GolfPass rating of just 1.7 is dramatically lower than you might expect from a course with that kind of reputation.
GolfPass lists Cochiti at just 1.7, compared with considerably higher ratings for many of the state's other public courses.
TripAdvisor tells a more complicated story. The course currently has a 4.0 rating from 57 reviews, but recent reviews include some harsh criticism of course conditions.
One June 2025 reviewer described the course as being in "catastrophic decline," particularly criticizing the greens, fairways and rough. Another reviewer in 2024 called the layout perhaps the best in New Mexico but complained about poor maintenance.
And there is evidence that conditions have improved. A TripAdvisor reviewer who played in April 2026 said the course was in great condition, with good staff and reasonable fees.
The takeaway: Cochiti's online reputation is complicated. The course has a spectacular layout and setting, but its GolfPass rating reflects a long history of complaints about conditioning.
2. Sonoma Ranch Golf Course — Las Cruces
![]() |
| Sonoma Ranch Golf Course |
GolfPass rating: 3.3/5 from 253 reviews
Sonoma Ranch doesn't have the rock-bottom rating of Cochiti, but its GolfPass numbers are noteworthy because they come from a much larger sample.
The Las Cruces course has a 3.3 GolfPass rating from 253 reviews, with only 58.3% of reviewers recommending it. Its weakest category is conditions, which GolfPass rates at just 2.8.
That makes the course particularly interesting because golfers generally like its layout, friendliness and pace of play. The problem appears to be getting the golf course itself into consistently good condition.
Recent GolfPass reviews have included complaints about dead grass, muddy areas and deteriorating conditions, although some golfers have also reported noticeable improvement.
TripAdvisor is considerably more forgiving. Sonoma Ranch currently carries a 4.0 rating from 37 reviews.
Still, recent TripAdvisor reviews have echoed some of the GolfPass complaints. One July 2025 golfer criticized the condition of the tee boxes and the restrictions on where carts could travel. Another 2024 reviewer described the course as dry and in need of a serious reclamation effort.
The takeaway: Sonoma Ranch isn't universally disliked. In fact, golfers frequently praise the layout, scenery and staff. But course conditioning has dragged down its GolfPass score.
3. Towa Golf Resort — Santa Fe
![]() |
| Towa Golf Resort |
GolfPass rating: 3.7/5 from 91 reviews
Towa Golf Resort is another course where the difference between the layout and the current playing conditions appears to be significant.
GolfPass lists the resort's three remaining nines—Boulder, Pinon and Valley—with a rating of approximately 3.7 from 91 reviews.
TripAdvisor currently gives Towa a much stronger overall rating than the worst courses in the state, but its recent reviews are strikingly negative.
A July 2025 reviewer called Towa the "Worst golf course in New Mexico," citing fairways and greens that were largely dirt and mud. Another 2025 reviewer described the course as "scorched earth golf," while a third called it possibly the worst-kept course he had ever played.
Perhaps most tellingly, one 2025 reviewer said the staff issued a full refund after the golfer saw the condition of the course.
But, again, there's another side to the story.
A May 2026 TripAdvisor review said Towa was getting better, noting new sod and ongoing efforts to improve the course. The reviewer still described some rough areas but said the layout and topography could make it a top-five course in New Mexico.
The takeaway: Towa may be a classic case of a golf course in transition. The scenery and architecture receive plenty of praise, while maintenance problems have produced some brutal reviews.
What About the Other Low-Rated Courses?
There are a few important honorable mentions.
Cree Meadows Golf Course in Ruidoso currently has just a 2.0 rating on TripAdvisor from six reviews, including one golfer who called it the worst course he had ever played and complained that most of the greens were virtually unplayable.
Isleta Eagle Golf Course is even lower, with a 1.0 TripAdvisor rating—but from just one review. That reviewer complained about dirt, worn tee boxes, wildlife waste and maintenance-related delays.
Those numbers are certainly worth noting, but the extremely small sample sizes make them less useful for ranking an entire state's golf courses.
That's why Cochiti, Sonoma Ranch and Towa make a more defensible three-course list when GolfPass and TripAdvisor are considered together.
The Bottom Line
New Mexico remains a terrific golf destination, and a low online rating doesn't necessarily mean you should permanently cross a course off your list.
In fact, the reviews suggest that course conditions are changing at several of these facilities. Cochiti has received positive recent reports after years of criticism, while Towa golfers have noticed improvement efforts. Sonoma Ranch also has golfers reporting that conditions are improving.
Still, if you're planning a New Mexico golf trip and want to maximize your chances of getting your money's worth, these are three courses where it's worth checking very recent reviews and current conditions before booking a tee time.
After all, there's a big difference between playing a course at its worst and catching it during its comeback.












