![]() |
| Clearview |
There are some spectacular golf courses in New York. Bethpage Black, Oak Hill, Winged Foot and countless others make the Empire State a bucket-list destination for golfers.
But not every New York golf course is earning rave reviews.
In fact, a handful of public courses are generating some brutally negative feedback from golfers, with complaints ranging from poor conditioning and neglected tee boxes to painfully slow play.
Here are three of the lowest-rated courses I found that are still open for play.
1. Clearview Park Golf Course — Bayside, Queens
If you've ever played golf in New York City, you know that convenience can come with a price.
Clearview Park Golf Course sits in Bayside, Queens, and its location is arguably its biggest selling point. The 18-hole municipal course sits near the Throgs Neck Bridge and provides some terrific views of the surrounding area.
The problem, according to a significant number of golfers, is the golf itself.
The course currently carries a 2.0-star rating from 34 reviews in the local business data I found.
Older Tripadvisor reviews have been particularly harsh, with complaints about poor fairway and green conditions, bird droppings and long waits. One reviewer described the waiting time as excruciating.
There are, however, signs that the course has been trying to improve. Current course information notes updated tees, a new 8,000-square-foot putting green and a remodeled clubhouse.
And that's an important distinction: a bad rating doesn't necessarily mean the course is permanently bad.
Clearview is open for play, with posted hours of 6 a.m. to 8 p.m. on most days. Clearview Park Golf Course
The verdict: If you're looking for pristine conditions, Clearview probably isn't the place. If you're looking for convenient New York City golf and don't mind the occasional rough edge, it's still an option.
2. Pelham Bay & Split Rock Golf Courses — The Bronx
![]() |
| Pelham Bay/Split Rock |
This one might surprise New York golfers.
Pelham Bay & Split Rock is actually a 36-hole public golf complex inside Pelham Bay Park in the Bronx. With two 18-hole courses and a huge amount of golf available, you'd expect the reviews to be better.
Instead, the facility currently carries a 2.5-star rating from 85 reviews in the business data.
That's enough reviews to make this one considerably more interesting than a course with only a handful of disgruntled golfers.
The complaints aren't necessarily about one catastrophic problem. Like many heavily played municipal facilities, the criticism tends to revolve around the overall experience, including pace of play and course conditions. At the same time, golfers also praise the value and the fact that you get 36 holes of golf relatively close to Manhattan. Pelham Bay and Split Rock Golf Courses
And there's another reason this course deserves some context.
You're playing in one of the largest urban parks in the country, not a private club tucked away in Westchester or the Hamptons. Expectations have to be adjusted accordingly.
The facility remains open for public play, with posted hours beginning at 6 a.m. most days. Pelham Bay and Split Rock Golf Courses
The verdict: The rating is ugly, but 36 holes, a convenient location and public-golf pricing make Pelham Bay/Split Rock more complicated than simply calling it "bad."
3. Sunken Meadow Golf Course — Fort Salonga
![]() |
| Sunken Meadow |
Here's the most interesting entry on the list.
Sunken Meadow Golf Course is part of Sunken Meadow State Park on Long Island and offers 27 holes of public golf. It's a beautiful setting, with the course located near Long Island Sound.
On one review platform, however, the course's Green nine carries an Eden score of just 2.9 out of 10, with only 25% of reviewers indicating they liked it. Recent reviews have included complaints about slow greens and poorly maintained tee boxes and fairways.
One recent reviewer gave it just 1 out of 10.
Another gave it 2.2.
And yet another reviewer in August 2026 gave it an 8.3.
That tells you everything you need to know about online golf reviews: they can be wildly subjective.
In fact, another golf-review site gives Sunken Meadow a 4.2 rating from 164 reviews, describing it as a scenic, affordable and walkable public course.
So why include it?
Because when you're looking for the worst-rated courses, Sunken Meadow's extremely low recent user scores are impossible to ignore.
And the course is definitely still open. The current business listing shows the facility operating seven days a week, while the course offers 27 holes and remains a New York State Parks facility. Sunken Meadow Golf Course
The verdict: Sunken Meadow may be the best example of why golfers shouldn't blindly trust a single rating. Some golfers absolutely hate it. Others think it's a very good value.
So, Are These Really New York's Worst Golf Courses?
That's the tricky part.
There is no official "worst golf courses in New York" ranking, and different review platforms produce dramatically different results.
That's particularly obvious with Sunken Meadow. One platform rates it poorly, while another has it at 4.2 stars based on 164 reviews.
And that's why I wouldn't interpret this list as "never play these courses."
Instead, think of it as three New York courses where golfers have been most critical recently.
If you're planning a golf trip, I'd look beyond the star rating and check the most recent reviews, current course conditions and pace-of-play reports before booking.
Because sometimes the difference between a terrible golf course and a pretty good one is simply when you played it.











